'The appearance of impropriety': Historic KM censure vote passes against Neisler
By Chuck Thompson | The Shelby Independent

KINGS MOUNTAIN, N.C. – Following the release and review of the investigative findings, the Kings Mountain City Council voted 6-0 Thursday night to censure Neisler, citing what the outside investigators described as an “appearance of impropriety” involving his communications and advocacy surrounding the proposed Land, Farm, Game development project.
“Did you meet with and did you have conversations with” was the reason for the meeting and the censure vote.
The censure investigation focused on the early months of Neisler’s return to council beginning in December 2025. He previously served as mayor from 2016-2024.
Following the release and review of the investigative findings, the Kings Mountain City Council voted Thursday night to censure Neisler, citing what the outside investigators described as an “appearance of impropriety” involving his communications and advocacy surrounding the proposed Land, Farm, Game development project.
“You put us in a bad spot,” Councilmember Jimmy West said to Scott Neisler during the proceedings.
Before all that, attorney Pat Flanagan, who was hired as outside counsel to conduct an investigation into whether Councilmember Scott Neisler had conducted himself in a way that would warrant a censure, read out his investigation’s findings. Flanagan noted that Neisler failed to disclose the extent of his relationship with individuals associated with Land Farm Game (LFG).
The censure followed an investigation that found no evidence of an actual financial conflict of interest or personal financial benefit to Neisler. However, investigators concluded that his continued communications with project representatives, efforts to encourage direct contact between developers and council members, and advocacy for the project outside established administrative channels created the appearance that the development was receiving special access or consideration.
While the investigators identified conduct they said created an “appearance of impropriety” under the city’s Code of Ethics, they did not establish that Neisler personally benefited financially from the project or possessed an actual conflict of interest.
Neisler was given a chance for rebuttal, where he said he had always put Kings Mountain first. He then read a written statement where he said he upholds the code of ethics and every elected official should be held accountable, including himself.
“Accountability must be grounded in facts, applied constantly, and separated from political disagreement,” stated Neisler.
Neisler went on to explain, in his defense, that he had only done what is always done and felt he did not violate any code of ethics, stating he was only attempting to get Kings Mountain City Manager Todd Carpenter to negotiate with LFG.
He accused the council of already having made their minds up to censure him before the night’s hearing due to wording on the agenda; a small wording choice that Neisler felt proved they were determined to censure him before the Nov. 19 meeting even started.
Neisler also fired a shot over the bow of the other council members, claiming, “And like me, some of you have also received legal campaign contributions from local developers, which follows election campaign laws.”
Neisler also claimed that since others had done the same thing, he would be watching them closely.
In closing, Neisler added, “Disagreement is not dishonesty. Advocacy is not personal gain, and asking questions is not in itself an abuse of office.”
Councilmember Tyler Fletcher objected to only his name being filed on the allegations. While noting the council had his full support, he stated for the record that since he did not witness any of the alleged improprieties, he did not understand why his name was attached to the charges against Neisler and that nobody could answer as to why his name was listed as one of the complainants. However, he did mention that all council members have a copy of the code of ethics and everyone must abide by it.
The council closed the hearing portion of the meeting and moved on to the discussion and deliberation portion of the public censure meeting, where the remaining council members spoke and at times clashed with Neisler.
“It’s a bad day,” stated Councilmember Jimmy West. “It’s a bad day for all of us.”
West followed up by telling Neisler that he had put them “in a bad spot,” while also noting nobody is perfect and everyone makes mistakes. West then told Neisler what bothered him the most was “you take money from the data center,” West stated. “You’re taking campaign money.”
Mayor Rob Wagman instructed West to stay on course about today’s findings.
“But that is a concern of mine,” West said to Neisler. “The arrogance of it bothers me, to be honesty. You pushed the data center on people.”
West continued, “… But again, you’ve put us in a bad spot, and I hold you accountable for that; not me, not the council, not these people up here – but you.”
West said he was at a loss for words and that Neisler probably was, too.
Neisler chimed in, replying, “I’m not – I’m really not. I’ve got some words.”
“That doesn’t surprise me,” added West. “You’ve never been at a loss of words.”
West and Neisler calmly sparred back and forth, with Neisler stating the data center didn’t give him any money – to West saying he knows exactly who it came from, an individual who was not named.
Mayor Wagman had to step in to remind them to stay on course.
“You said you met with them, too.” Neisler quipped.
“I did,” replied West, “but I didn’t take any money from them!”
The sparring slightly intensified as West and Neisler argued across the council chambers floor, with Neisler stating there’s nothing wrong with meeting with representatives from the data center and West stating Neisler was calling people in Kings Mountain, having them come look at the property.
“I didn’t say that,” Neisler replied. “I did not do that.”
“You’re telling me that you didn’t call citizens to come up here and meet with Nick Hendrick?” asked West.
“I did not,” Neisler replied.
“There’s people in this room that’ll say just the opposite,” West stated firmly.
The gavel slammed as Mayor Wagman interceded to remind them to focus.
Then Neisler and Wagman talked over one another until they could be brought back to civility.
“There were findings,” explained Wagman. “And that’s why we’re here today; there were findings. So, if we can, council, with respect to the reason we’re here, let’s keep it in line as to why we are here and try not to go outside of those lines.”
Again, West and Neisler started talking over one another, as West said Neisler was pushing a data center on the citizens of Kings Mountain for what he claimed Neisler wanted – to which Neisler denied his accusations. The talking between the two overlapped, and it was difficult to make out everything each one was saying at various times.
Neisler then said, “All I was trying to do was to get management to sit down at the table, which is their responsibility.”
Councilmember Heather Lemmond spoke next, adding her thoughts and clarifying reasons for the censure. “It’s not about feelings,” in summary, she explained. “It’s about code of ethics.”
Lemmond stated the whole reason was as stated in the investigation.
“It says, ‘We should avoid the appearance of impropriety as well’,” said Lemmond.
She went on to state that the facts are there, regardless of the intent, and any reasonable person looking at all of this would “question whether private interests were mixed with public duty.”
She also said that the opportunity for Neisler to “correct course” and “right the ship” was available many times, and it did not happen.
Lemmond said this was a dangerous precedent being set which would affect how business is handled in the future. Her comments were her way of correcting course before it became acceptable to continue as this had happened.
Lemmond scolded Neisler by explaining that, as a new councilmember, she looked to others to learn from and set examples.
“I want the stability of government to guide me,” she noted. “And I honestly expected someone like you, with so much experience, to be one of those people to guide me.”
Councilmember Shearra Miller spoke next, noting she regretted that this was even taking place. She also expressed to Neisler that this was not based on who likes him or dislikes him but on the code of ethics.

She noted how several people asked her why they were investigating Neisler, stating he is a good person, to which she could only reply, “Code of ethics.”
“We’re all elected to serve our citizens and with that responsibility becomes the obligation to conduct ourselves with integrity, transparency and accountability…”
Miller continued, “An ethics violation is not something that should just be brushed aside or ignored.”
Miller also was curious about City Manager Todd Carpenter being accused by Neisler of not engaging with LFG, to which Carpenter responded to the allegation made against him.
“That is simply not the fact,” stated Carpenter, as he mentioned to the board that he had prepared a statement to read to the council.
In summary, he denied the allegations that he had not kept in contact with Land, Farm and Game. Carpenter spoke on the code of ethics and how his professionalism and decisions had been called into question at times.
Carpenter stated that he and other staff had repeatedly met with representatives of LFG. He noted he had kept the council updated on their meetings over time, but then Carpenter dropped a hammer of an allegation as he stated to the council that Neisler had met with him not long after Neisler had been sworn in and requested that Carpenter give LFG 20 megawatts of electricity.
This was followed by him stating that Neisler told him not to mention this to the other city council members.
The city manager claimed that after Neisler was elected, he came to him on more than one occasion and asked him to give Land, Farm and Game, the developers of the data center property, 20 megawatts of electricity and not to tell the other city council members.
“Twenty megawatts is not an insignificant amount of power for a municipal electric utility,” stated Carpenter. “It is a substantial public resource and must be managed responsibly and in the best interest of our citizens and existing customers.”
He rebuked the idea of one council member having sway over all others.
“As a city manager, I work for the city council as a governing body. I do not work for an individual council member,” acknowledged Carpenter. “I cannot withhold material city business from council, nor can I allow an individual elected official to direct administrative decisions that have not been authorized by the governing body. I documented these concerns and communicated them through the appropriate channels.”
After more from Carpenter and a brief discussion with Wagman on whether Neisler could respond, Neisler turned to Carpenter and spoke to him like an attorney in a courtroom, “Do you deny that you sent an email –.”
The mayor immediately interjected, “Scott, this is not a hearing.” Wagman said he could make statements but not ask him questions that he did not have to answer.
Neisler denied the accusation of telling City Manager Carpenter their discussions should be kept private from other council members.
Neisler claimed the part about keeping it from the council was about sending a kid to college. Wagman stated that he remembered the time in question and that they had not yet begun discussing sending the kid to college.
Neisler then started talking about water; stating how the town had only two days of water at the time. Mayor Wagman banged on the gavel several times, calling Neisler’s name as Neisler kept talking to Carpenter, ignoring the direction of the mayor.
“Council is not here to speak on those items,” Wagman stated.
Neisler protested that he let Carpenter speak on unrelated topics.
Neisler then explained that the 20 megawatts of power was an offer the developers made to the city since the city lost the casino power. Neisler said it would help service the debt for the City of Kings Mountain.
Wagman said it wasn’t about the megawatts but about whether Neisler met with and discussed with (land developers in private).
Councilmember Annie Thombs spoke next.
She spoke on when Neisler would continue to talk about LFG as things were already going through the motion. She stated that Neisler seemed to be doing things for himself more than for the City of Kings Mountain.
“You have worked against the policy and procedures, and that’s why we’re here tonight,” said Thombs.
“I remember clearly when the city manager came to us about Land Farm and Game, and those of us that were on council at that time, after about the third meeting, we asked the city manager to stop it. We did not trust the players. They did not have a relationship with the truth, and so we said, ‘Stop it.’ The city manager said, ‘I do not want the city to miss out on an opportunity if it’s a good opportunity. So, if you all will allow me to pursue it, then I will get Land Farm and Game to reimburse us for the money that we spend while we investigate.’
And no matter how many times we said to Councilman Neisler, ‘It’s going through the process,’ he refused to hear it. It was like he wanted it his way, and that’s the way it was going to be. And not only that, during council meetings, he would bring it up, make statements.”
“An appearance isn’t anything that holds water,” stated Neisler. He also stated that he didn’t feel he violated the code of ethics for, “Doing my homework and trying to figure out what was a good project for the citizens of Kings Mountain.”
Several council members responded with “Appearance is in our code of conduct.”
Neisler claimed to allegedly have documentation that all the council members had done similar things in the past, except for Lemmond, who is new to the council.
But then Neisler said Miller had received campaign contributions from PACs (Political Action Committees), to which Miller immediately replied, “No.”
“Yes,” responded Neisler.
“I have never received a campaign contribution from a PAC,” she stated.
Wagman once again had to remind the council to focus on the topic at hand.
Neisler accused the mayor of slandering him, to which Wagman denied, adding, “We are here to determine: Did you meet with and have conversations with –.”
“Of course I did,” Neisler agreed.
“Thank you for your admission,” replied Wagman.
“And I applaud all of y’all that did the same thing,” Neisler added.
The vote was taken, and the censure against Neisler passed unanimously.
No other information was given. The council then immediately adjourned.

Follow The Shelby Independent on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. To contact Chuck about a story idea, send an email or visit the contact page.
Chuck Thompson is a reporter and columnist for The Shelby Independent.

2026 THE SHELBY INDEPENDENT.















Comments